SCIENOPS / SCIENCE & EVIDENCE
Make the reasoning as inspectable as the result.
Make the reasoning as inspectable as the result.
A defensible conclusion connects the claim, the source, the analytical method and the conditions under which it holds.
Embedded Files
ORIGIN
Distinguish the kind of support.
Distinguish the kind of support.
Experimental observations, computational predictions, registry records and observational datasets answer different questions. Preserve those distinctions when evidence is combined or summarised.
CONTEXT
Test relevance to the intended decision.
Test relevance to the intended decision.
Examine the biological setting, population, comparison, time and measurement conditions. Evidence can be sound in its original context yet insufficient to support a different use.
UNCERTAINTY
Identify what could change the conclusion.
Identify what could change the conclusion.
Separate missing information, conflicting findings, limited coverage and method mismatch. Each calls for a different response: another source, a new comparison, a revised analysis or a narrower claim.
REVIEW
Define the standard and the responsible reviewer.
Define the standard and the responsible reviewer.
Agree the evidence needed for the proposed use and who can approve it. Software verification, scientific validation and acceptance within the operating process are distinct responsibilities.
A USEFUL EVIDENCE PACK
A record that others can examine and build on.
A record that others can examine and build on.
Include the question, source versions, methods, assumptions, results, limitations and unresolved gaps. Record the interpretation, decision owner, agreed action and conditions for reconsidering it.
WHEN THE ANSWER IS NOT READY
Make an unresolved result useful.
Make an unresolved result useful.
An inconclusive review should identify the missing support and the work needed to resolve it. A documented pause, narrower claim or change in method can protect the programme from an unsupported commitment.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse